Canada Bleeding Millions on Cruel Seal Hunt

By on March 7, 2016 with 11 Comments By Wayne Pacelle

In my forthcoming book, The Humane Economy, I explore the many ways that businesses and governments can do better for themselves and for the rest of us if they embrace animal welfare as a core concern. What has become apparent in recent decades is that industries that compromise animal welfare can cost society many times the revenues they generate, often in the form of externalities that taxpayers, property owners, and others must contend with.

In past centuries, commercial whaling was a mainstay of some coastal communities. But as society overwhelmingly rejected the killing of whales as morally repugnant, and as new forms of energy were developed to make whale oil obsolete, the industry withered and governments stepped in to forbid the practice. A humane alternative far more in line with public values rapidly emerged: whale watching. But whale watching wasn’t just a more humane way for society to interact with whales; it was ultimately far more lucrative for the communities involved.

In the case of commercial sealing, public opinion is clearly in favor of stopping the slaughter. But the Canadian government has yet to accept that the seal hunt is a clear economic loser. It is upside-down in terms of its economic benefits.  Canada’s new prime minister, Justin Trudeau, is coming soon to the United States, and we hope he takes a look at the economic issues surrounding it.

Files obtained by Humane Society International through Canada’s Access to Information laws reveal that the Canadian government is spending $2.5 million each year just to monitor the commercial seal hunt, which had an export value of only $500,000 in 2014. And that doesn’t take into account the many millions more in subsidies and financing that the Canadian and provincial governments sink into product purchasing, development, processing, and marketing every year.

The Canadian government must be painfully aware that the economics of the Atlantic seal hunt make no sense. So why is it continuing to subsidize an activity far more suited to the 18th century than a modern society? Because it is politically expedient for them to do so as long as a few powerful fisheries associations continue to endorse the killing. And though most Canadians oppose the clubbing and shooting of baby seals for their fur, in an internal memo from 2014, the government just writes that off as people being “stupid” and needing more “education.”

The tragedy is that in continuing to disrespect the views of its citizens by supporting and financing a cruel and outdated slaughter, the Canadian government is not just throwing good money after bad, it is denying coastal communities a far better future and putting them in an anti-competitive position as the rest of the world develops robust ecotourism projects.

Canada is a first-world nation and this is the 21st century. Marine ecotourism is just one of the many sustainable industries that could easily be developed in the coastal communities currently involved in commercial sealing. But a political mind shift is required to secure the investment required from the Canadian government. Until that happens, The HSUS and HSI will continue to expose the plight of seals and work to stop the trade in the products of this bloody slaughter. Our case starts with our moral claims, but it is clinched with our economic arguments.


Subscribe to the Blog

Enter your email address below to receive updates each time we publish new content.


Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. David Bernazani says:

    The annual Canadian seal slaughter is so repugnant, so economically disastrous, and so condemned by the rest of the world, I though for sure that it would have stopped long before now– certainly before Ringling’s stopped using elephants and SeaWorld stopped using orcas in their shows.
    The world is quickly becoming aware of its ethical responsibilities towards its “junior citizens”, and clubbing baby seals for their skins has no place in it today. Canada, the world is watching; time to stop the cruelty.

    • della lindquist says:

      Yes! I think more tourists would come and see the ice and Canada if they knew the clubbing had stopped!!!

  2. Sally Palmer says:

    This blog presents the clear economic facts against seal slaughter that benefits only a few. The HSUS’s persistence in presenting the reality of the damage being done to Canada will overcome political resistance eventually; it certainly inspires people to keep on fighting to end this barbarism. In the meantime, Canada looks like the land of monsters and idiots condoning greed and savagery at the expense of its wildlife and its economy.

  3. Rosemary Tofexis says:

    his is totally inhumane and disgusting!!!!! These poor babies don’t have a chance and need us to help them!! God put them on this earth to be free, just as us humans!!! We do not own them!!! Please stop these madmen from doing this horrendous act!!!!! They are not human if they can club a baby seal!! How despicable! Make “Faux Seal Skin” Products, like they do everything else and leave these babies alone!!!! God help them.!!!!

  4. Lynn Kennedy says:

    Canadians, if you are against this, come to Parliament Hill March 19 at noon for a peaceful protest to end this practice. Please come out and support those of us who are fighting this barbarism in our country.

  5. maria nunes says:

    Please stop …!!!

  6. sempere says:

    contre cette tuerie

  7. ReNay says:

    Please sign and share!!!! We need to end this cruelty!!!!

  8. Lesa Foster says:

    This is disgusting behavior and needs to stop now! It is so cruel and inhumane how these poor baby seals are killed. Make faux seal skins just like others and stop killing these innocent babies!

  9. Micheal says:

    I was looking evhreweyre and this popped up like nothing!

  10. Peter L. says:

    Wayne, you conveniently forget to mention the thousands of Inuit who rely on seal hunting has their main source of food and income. In remote regions of northern Canada where a head of cabbage can cost $30, seals are a cheap and nutritional source of food. By advocating for the banning of seal hunting you are advocating for food insecurity for these folks as well as carrying out cultural genocide.

    I’d like to point out that a big difference between whales and seals is that whales are endangered while seals are plentiful. The Inuit have a tremendous amount of respect for seals and use every part of the seal.

    I urge people reading this to educate themselves about how anti-seal-hunting efforts are destroying already-marginalized Inuit communities. Peace.

Share a Comment

The HSUS encourages open discussion, and we invite you to share your opinion on our issues. By participating on this page, you are agreeing to our commenting policy.
Please enter your name and email address below before commenting. Your email address will not be published.