Oklahoma Lawmakers Try Sending a Lifeline to Puppy Mill Operators

By on March 9, 2016 with 7 Comments By Wayne Pacelle

Our lifesaving raid on a puppy mill in Madison County, Arkansas, last week – where our team, working with law enforcement, rescued 295 dogs who were covered in filth and feces and denied access to clean water or any kind of medical care – got me to thinking about the special and indispensable role that The HSUS plays in animal protection.

We learned about this crisis through our puppy mill tip line, and we worked with the local sheriff, whose office in this rural county lacked the resources to handle 295 dogs. Few have such capacity and local humane organizations are often too overburdened to handle a human-caused animal emergency of this scale. That’s where we come in.

Leading a diverse coalition of staff, highly trained local humane experts, and RedRover volunteers, we set up an emergency shelter at the Humane Society of Saline County, provided much needed emergency medical care, and worked with our shelter partners to place the dogs in homes. It was a seamless operation, and animals who were knocking on death’s door just a few days ago are now beginning a much more hopeful chapter of their lives.

Ironically, just a week before that raid, representatives in the neighboring state of Oklahoma passed a bill, introduced by Representative Brian Renegar, to  prevent any “animal rights charitable organization” from fundraising in Oklahoma for out-of-state operations, if the organization isn’t constituted “primarily for companion animals” or if the group conducts any lobbying activities to help animals

Setting aside the matter that this bill is obviously unconstitutional, let’s consider a few facts and ironies.

Without the ability to raise funds in Oklahoma (and other states should they try to replicate this legislative maneuver), we would not have the resources to come in and provide this kind of help for companion animals in crisis – in Oklahoma or just over the border in Arkansas or in Kansas or Texas. Animal cruelty has no boundaries, and when animals are in trouble, it’s vital that there’s someone to answer the call.

Had there been no tip line, there would have been no obvious pathway to learn about the dire conditions that the animals were living in. Had there been no local group that we had supplied with rescue equipment and expertise and animal care staff, there would have been no rescue. More animals would have died, and the puppy mill operator would have simply continued to bring more animals into this hell, churning through them as if they were unfeeling commodities.

Why would Oklahoma lawmakers try to prevent an intervention stopping this kind of cruelty? Why would they try to prevent a collaboration between animal rescue groups and local law enforcement, and the arrest of a person causing so much harm to animals just over the Oklahoma line, in neighboring Arkansas?  Are beleaguered and dying animals just across the border in Arkansas any less deserving of rescue and help than animals in Oklahoma are (where these same lawmakers are blocking reforms to crack down on puppy mills in their state and passing legislation to block us from lobbying for such measures)?

These are rhetorical questions because we know the answers.

We know that the lawmakers behind this effort get their talking points from the Farm Bureau and other agribusiness interests, and that their demonstrably unconstitutional bill (with a version now introduced in neighboring Missouri) is a frustrated, hyperventilating response to the feeling of helplessness among certain animal-use groups faced with our reform efforts. These players don’t like our lifesaving and game-changing work against puppy mills or cockfighting. And they certainly don’t like our work for farm animals – determined efforts that have resulted in 75 of the biggest food retail brands in the United States pledging to phase out their purchase of pork and eggs from operations that confine animals so severely that they cannot even turn around.

Feeling like this change is unwarranted, these interests lash out and try to disable all of our work – whether it is to help horses, wildlife, farm animals, or companion animals.

We have free-speech rights to speak our mind and to solicit the support of Oklahomans or the people of any other state. Oklahomans and other citizens have their own free-speech rights to give to the charities of their choice.

But the question remains for these lawmakers. Would these people have been happy to see these dogs just over the border in Arkansas languish and die?  I assure you, no one else was lining up to help them. There are countless cases of cruelty and neglect. We get to some good number of them with our tireless efforts, but if The HSUS didn’t have enough resources to get to this one, it’s very likely no one else would have.

I ask you, Representative Brian Renegar, would that outcome have pleased you?

Support the lifesaving work of our Animal Rescue Team »

Animal Rescue and Care, Companion Animals, Public Policy (Legal/Legislative)

Subscribe to the Blog

Enter your email address below to receive updates each time we publish new content.


Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. David Morgan says:

    It appears that Representative Renegar is a practicing veterinarian! I can’t see why he would sponsor such a bill! Representative Renegar, will you please respond to the points made in the blog? I’m really interested – especially in light of the in-humane cases around you.

  2. Marie Risk says:

    What type of people don’t see puppy mills for what they are? What type of low lives have no respect for animal life? I guess the type that govern Oklahoma. These people sleep at night because they have no empathy in their sorry a_ _ bones. They couldn’t care less about these helpless dogs.
    They make me sick. On another note, thank you HSUS and thank you Wayne for fighting the fight and many times winning. Thank you so much!

  3. Sally Palmer says:

    This is heartbreaking and frightening that anyone could be so evil. But I see so much progress by The HSUS on so many fronts, I am lifted up from despair by that. I just saw the commercial with Kaley Cuoco today, and it was wonderful, and I know it will educate people into action on behalf of helping animal beings. While my other experience today didn’t have to do with puppy mills, it showed how much ground has been made in other areas. I went to a Wellness Lunch and Learn and it had plant-based diets for the program, and I saw 35 people moved to trying plant-based diets in varying degrees. While it was just for their health, at least their changes in consumption will take away from the vicious animal product industry. Last I heard consumer demand can’t be made illegal, although I wouldn’t put anything past people like Brian Renegar.

  4. P. Woodward says:

    What is the phone no. for Oklahoma puppy mill tip line?
    There is a puppy mill operating out of Grove, Ok- lists dogs on Craig’s list
    Know of a papillon / beagle purchased there!

  5. Stacy McDaniel says:

    I think this is terrible. Oklahoma is consistently in the bottom of the rankings when it comes to punishing the perpetrators of horrendous animal abuse. To introduce a law that would make it even more difficult for people to help is very short sighted and would have severe ramifications in the long run when it comes to helping animals.

  6. nancy messer says:

    To those that think puppy mills are a good thing how about each of those people be put in a nasty cage to live for awhile with no place to potty,rotten food little water and no space in which to turn around or lie down may be then these stupid people will understand the horrific pain and suffering these animals go through ! The gag laws are just to keep the appalling treatment of animals on going…who in their right mind would want such suffering ..apparently a lot of low lives in all areas of life thinks its ok……Times are changing and a number of wise compassion people will not allow animals to pay a price for our greedy, cruel actions. Thank heaven we have brave warriors that will keep fighting for those that have no voice…to you I say THANK YOU !!!!

Share a Comment

The HSUS encourages open discussion, and we invite you to share your opinion on our issues. By participating on this page, you are agreeing to our commenting policy.
Please enter your name and email address below before commenting. Your email address will not be published.