Beulah’s death is a wake-up call for Massachusetts lawmakers to ban wild animals in traveling acts

By on September 20, 2019 with 9 Comments

So many of us were saddened this week to learn about the death of Beulah the elephant, who spent most of her 54 years in captivity and chains, working for a Connecticut-based traveling petting zoo.

Beulah was just six years old when she was sold to the R. W. Commerford & Sons Traveling Petting Zoo. Although she was born in the wild in Myanmar, this elephant would never know what it was like to live free. Instead, she spent most of her life entertaining children and families at circuses and fairs, including The Big E, an agricultural fair in West Springfield, Massachusetts. Her owners did not even allow her to retire in her old age: just days before she died, she was seen ailing at The Big E.

Last year, a photo of Minnie, another elephant owned by Commerford who was forced to give rides to visitors at The Big E despite the fact that she looked sick, went viral on social media.

Beulah’s life – and her death – are stark reminders of the cruelties wild animals like elephants face when they are forced into captivity and life in traveling zoos and circuses. That’s why we are calling on lawmakers in Massachusetts, home to The Big E, to pass a bill now before them that would prohibit the use of elephants, big cats, primates and bears in circuses and traveling shows in the state.

Traveling zoos and circuses are no place for elephants or for any wild animal. The animals in these enterprises are confined for prolonged periods in dark and unventilated trucks and trailers as they are hauled from venue to venue for months at a time. When they are not performing, elephants are chained or confined to small pens and big cats are kept in transport cages that typically measure approximately four feet by seven feet – barely bigger than the animals themselves.

The animals are routinely deprived of adequate exercise, veterinary care, or even regular food and water by exhibitors whose primary concern is heading out of one town to set up in the next. Trainers use physical abuse, including beatings and instruments like bullhooks, electric prods, whips, chains and muzzles, to coerce animals to perform difficult tricks. Elephants are forced into headstands, bears are made to do handstands, and tigers are made to “moon walk” on their hind legs – all unnatural maneuvers that place great stress on animals’ muscles and joints and can result in long-term injuries.

This is why groups like ours have campaigned for decades to end wild animal acts, and the first big break for elephants came in 2016, when Ringling Bros. said it would end its use of elephants. The same year, California and Rhode Island banned the use of bullhooks on elephants. In 2017, Ringling went on to shutter its operation entirely, and Illinois and New York both banned the use of elephants in traveling shows. Subsequently, more states passed laws to protect wild animals in circuses, including New Jersey, which bans most wild animals in traveling shows, and Hawaii, which bans the import of wild animals into the state for circuses and other exhibitions. Municipalities across the country are also responding to citizen concerns. Use our toolkit to find out how you can pass an ordinance in your city, county or state.

These shows also no longer make good business sense. With more consumers now educated about the cruelties wild animals face in circuses, traveling wild animal acts are dwindling in popularity and ticket sales. Others have successfully shifted away from an animal-centered business model.

We are making progress at a remarkable pace, but Beulah’s heartbreaking story reminds us, once again, that we cannot move too fast to end the suffering and pain of innocent animals. The outpouring of concern over her death, reflected both on social media platforms and in the news media, should serve as a clarion call to lawmakers in Massachusetts to act on this important legislation. It’s too late for Beulah, but they can ensure that no other elephant – or any wild animal — suffers again at The Big E and other fairs and circuses in the Bay State.

Massachusetts residents, ask your lawmakers to support S. 2028 and H. 2934.

Public Policy (Legal/Legislative), Wildlife/Marine Mammals

Subscribe to the Blog

Enter your email address below to receive updates each time we publish new content.


Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Angela Grammatico says:

    When are you going to STOP “the torturous abuse these poor animals endore for human greed !!! Do your jobs correctly !!

  2. Bridgette Kronlage says:

    Unacceptable that you allow this ongoing abuse of elephants and other wild animals in traveling shows. Damn all of you to hell!

  3. Linda Francipane says:

    Boycott all animal prisons?

  4. Susan Walajtys says:

    Traveling petting zoos and circuses are as bad as chain gangs of enslaved prisoners, except that the animals committed no crime. Animal keepers are the guilty ones who dominate, hurt, and use God’s creatures for money and greed, denying the animals their simplest most natural needs. Tolerating animal rides and forced animal performances teaches an indifference to animals which is morally unacceptable. Please be compassionate and end these events that destroy animals with violence and neglect.

    • Dee says:

      Your kindness is greatly appreciated and, as it truly encouraged me- I’m sure your words have had a positive effect on all others to support humane and loving behaviors toward all wildlife also🌈💟

  5. Fran Shaheen says:

    STOP this ABUSE! Human beings are so greedy and will exploit anything. They are so full of lust. Stop the torture our lawmakers are not doing their jobs they are allowing all of this to happen and they don’t care as long as they got their big mansions and electric cars they don”t care who they kill.

  6. Deb Lill says:

    Ban wild animals at circuses

  7. Patricia Lamonica says:


Share a Comment

The HSUS encourages open discussion, and we invite you to share your opinion on our issues. By participating on this page, you are agreeing to our commenting policy.
Please enter your name and email address below before commenting. Your email address will not be published.