Another gas chamber at an animal shelter is banished to history, with a dozen more to go

By on February 20, 2020 with 17 Comments

The euthanasia of homeless companion animals in gas chambers sounds archaic and is inhumane, but the practice is still prevalent in four states—Ohio, Missouri, Utah and Wyoming—where there are fewer than a dozen such chambers in operation.

That’s still too many. Since 2013, the Humane Society of the United States has made it our mission to dismantle every gas chamber in the country. We have helped fund, with incentive grants, the demolition of more than 75 chambers–that’s two-thirds of the total number operating nationwide since we began this work. And this month, we helped one more animal shelter, in West Plains, Missouri, with a financial grant so it could relegate its gas chamber to history. This is the fourth chamber we have closed down in the state so far.

Death in a gas chamber can be painful and excruciating. The animals are placed in the small, dark box, and they may remain conscious for several minutes, terrified and trying desperately to find a way out. Shelters sometimes place multiple animals in the box, despite guidelines that state only one animal should be in the gas chamber at a time, which can lead to more stress and panic for the animals. They may begin convulsing before they lose consciousness, and death can be especially slow to come for animals who are very young or old or sick.

This is no way for any animal to face the end of his or her life. There have even been rare cases of animals surviving the chamber, only to end up alive in a landfill.

This month, we helped one more animal shelter, in West Plains, Missouri, with a financial grant so it could relegate its gas chamber to history. This is the fourth chamber we have closed down in the state so far.

Gas chambers are also more expensive than the humane alternative–euthanasia by injection; they pose risk of injury and even death to shelter staff, and they have been condemned for routine shelter euthanasia by the American Veterinary Medical Association, the Humane Society Veterinary Medical Association and every other national animal welfare organization.

It is clear that gas chambers have no place in animal shelters, and we have attacked the problem methodically. In addition to working with shelters and issuing grants to close down chambers, our state directors have taken the fight to their statehouses. Although 46 states no longer use gas chambers, 32 states do not have laws banning them. There’s now a bill in the Ohio Senate that would ban gas chambers (the state still has one operating gas chamber) and we will be putting our might behind passing it.

Lawmakers in Utah (which has six gas chambers, although not all are operational) and Wyoming (which has four operating gas chambers) are considering similar language. We expect bills to be introduced there over the coming year.

Vermont does not have any gas chambers, but this year a bill in the state’s House of Delegates would close a loophole in state law that still allows for their use, thus aligning the law with existing practices of local animal shelters.

Most Americans see cats and dogs as family members, and there is growing momentum nationwide to reduce pet homelessness and work toward higher adoption rates. The HSUS has been at the forefront of the movement, through programs like the Shelter Pet Project, a public awareness campaign that urges would-be adopters to make shelters their first choice when adding a pet to their family; our Shelter Ally Project, which pairs struggling shelters with more successful peers to offer mentorship and save more lives beyond their own facilities; and our Pets For Life program, which helps keep pets with loving families in underresourced areas.

Through our Puppy Friendly Pet Stores program we are helping pet stores partner with local shelters and rescue groups to increase homeless pet adoption and end the problem of puppy mills.

Lawmakers too are moving to recognize companion animals who end up in shelters. Six states, including Ohio, Colorado, California, Georgia, Illinois and Tennessee have designated shelter pets as their state pets. Florida, Kentucky and Virginia will likely do the same this year.

But honoring shelter pets should also come with a commitment to ensure that they are treated with compassion during every stage of their journey, and especially at the end of life. While we recognize that there will always be a need to end the suffering of animals who are experiencing untreatable and severe medical and behavioral challenges, the least we can do is offer the animals a painless death, not the horror of a gas chamber. We congratulate West Plains on taking the important step of eliminating its chamber. Our work to close down gas chambers and reduce pet homelessness will continue full-steam ahead in coming days.

Companion Animals, Public Policy (Legal/Legislative)

Subscribe to the Blog

Enter your email address below to receive updates each time we publish new content.


Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Alan Alejandro Maldonado Ortiz says:

    Ya no podemos seguir así como sociedad nada más matando los animales por culpa de nosotros mismos tenemos que hacernos responsables y cuidar a los animalitos ellos no necesitan

  2. Michele Jankelow says:

    OMW! What sort of society would EVER endorse such abject horrors? Absolutely diabolical! WW2 showed the horrors of this!!!!!

  3. Susan Heron- brown says:

    This is really very bad news to read about.
    It is really heartbreaking that our wonderful animals must suffer so much and end up in such a painful death.
    How is that Ok in 2020 when a vet could really do this in a way that could be a peaceful death. Why do people even have animals if they can’t promise to give them a forever home? It is really a crime.

  4. Fran Leard says:

    I can’t believe these filthy chambers still exists. What is wrong with these idiots to put these unlawful laws in effect? This is an outrage and so horrible.
    Close every one of them down immediately.

  5. sybil sloan says:

    It does make one sick to read about these gas chambers. However, it might be good to realize that years ago, no one knew what actually went on. Now, finally, things are changing. It was just thought that dogs were painlessly euthanized – obviously not so. I am grateful to HSUS for its work in opening our eyes (and hearts ) to what really is ‘out there ‘. When we truly know about something, then hopefully, we can make a difference.

  6. Helen Hoag says:

    Gas chambers were supposed to all be shut down several years ago according to government regulations. I do not understand why they are still being used. It is a horrible death.

  7. Helen Hoag says:

    Gas chambers were supposed to all be shut down several years ago according to government regulations. I do not understand why they are still being used. It is a horrible death. This administration is the most anti Animal ever and we do not need these people in any government office.

  8. ingrid rund says:

    I think the shelters are causing excessive barriers to adopt animals. I’m a responsible member of society, but have been repeatedly turned down by shelters for reasons such as “working” or believe it not, for allowing my dog to spend time outside. It’s really astounding to be turned down by these shelters for ridiculous reasons, and the animals remain in a cage or are euthanised. I’ve seen articles on the barriers to adoption, and I can testify to the barriers being excessive!!!! I have no choice but to buy a dog from a breeder or puppymill. I think we as a society should address this problem rather than allow unnecessary euthanasia.

  9. marcia frisella says:

    I am an advocate in banning their use= I abhor their use and will continue to fight until every last one is gone for good- The pain, fear and horror the animals experience in these chambers is beyond belief- Ohio, Missouri, Wyoming, and Utah (which I am dealing with at this time and writing Utah legislatures) still have them in use- Please join the fight to end this barbaric practice-

    • shell berman says:

      I agree with you Marcia. I just moved from Mo. and the small town I came from still uses the gas chamber. How can we stop this in Mo.

    • shell berman says:

      Marcia please e=mail me when you get a chance. I am looking for people who feel as strongly as I do about ending gas chambers in shelters.

      • marcia L frisella says:

        Hi Shell, I am just seeing this now- my apologies- I have sent you an email and we can discuss this more in depth. I would like to find out more about where in Missouri this is taking place. Marcia

        • Marisol Balderas says:

          What is being done now in Missouri, Ohio, Wyoming and Utah to put an end to these gas chambers? I’m sure if Texas was able to stop using this cruel method these 4 states can join in and put an end to this. Where’s the empathy and compassion?

  10. C.M. says:

    All euthanasia is not humane. No animal should ever be killed.

  11. Pat Gray says:

    Your exactly right the fees and reasons are ridiculous I was turned down cause on my farm I have woods and might have ticks. I said there are tick. in cities too. Really bad

  12. Crystal says:

    I live in Missouri and want to get involved. Who can I contact?

Share a Comment

The HSUS encourages open discussion, and we invite you to share your opinion on our issues. By participating on this page, you are agreeing to our commenting policy.
Please enter your name and email address below before commenting. Your email address will not be published.