Victory! Federal appeals court agrees Yellowstone grizzly bears should remain protected from trophy hunters

By Kitty Block and Sara Amundson

By on July 8, 2020 with 14 Comments

A federal appeals court has agreed that Yellowstone grizzly bears should continue to receive protection under the U.S. Endangered Species Act, ensuring that these iconic American carnivores will not be hunted for trophies.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a unanimous opinion today upholding a 2018 court victory that returned grizzly bears in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem to the federal list of threatened species. ​This ruling was a result of consolidated lawsuits filed by the Humane Society of the United States, allied conservation organizations and native American tribes, after the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, in June 2017, prematurely yanked federal ESA protections from Greater Yellowstone area grizzly bears and handed management authority to Idaho, Montana and Wyoming, the states surrounding Yellowstone.

Immediately, Wyoming and Idaho wildlife officials launched plans to allow trophy hunters to legally kill up to two dozen grizzly bears—plans we quickly thwarted by obtaining a temporary restraining order from a federal district court in Montana. The court sided with us again, overturning the FWS delisting in 2018.

In its ruling today, the appeals court agreed with the district court that the FWS cut corners and ignored science when it rushed to remove federal protections for these animals. The court also recognized that the government failed to consider the impacts that removing protections for grizzly bears in the Yellowstone ecosystem would have on other, even more imperiled, grizzly populations in the United States.

Today’s ruling affirms that grizzly bears will remain listed as threatened, protecting them from trophy hunting seasons that would otherwise take place in Wyoming, Idaho and, eventually, Montana. The court also criticized the FWS’s decision to rubber-stamp the states’ dubious, pro-trophy-hunting conservation strategy, as well as the agency’s failure to ensure that the long-term genetic health of the population would be secure without federal protections.

This is a huge win, with the potential for long-term, positive impacts for grizzly bears in Yellowstone and the rest of the United States. Kudos to our legal team and our wildlife management team who fought relentlessly for years for this outcome. Trophy hunting organizations and the gun lobby, including Safari Club International and the NRA, opposed us tooth and nail all the way, appealing parts of the district court decision that even FWS did not, but in the end the grizzly bears won.

America’s grizzly bears already face too many challenges to their survival today, including dwindling food resources, escalating human-caused mortality and state wildlife managers who unfairly malign bears based on perceived threats to livestock, even where there is little evidence that individual bears actually pose a significant threat to cattle or other animals grazing on federal and private land. We are happy for the role we have played in ensuring they continue to thrive and survive, but this battle may not be over yet. Our federal government, and the states bordering Yellowstone, have repeatedly shown themselves to be close allies of trophy hunters, and we remain on guard to ward off any future threats. For now, we are grateful our courts have recognized the importance of strong federal protections to the survival of these native carnivores and stand ready to hold government agencies accountable when they circumvent our most important wildlife protection laws.

Sara Amundson is president of the Humane Society Legislative Fund.

Public Policy (Legal/Legislative), Wildlife/Marine Mammals

Subscribe to the Blog

Enter your email address below to receive updates each time we publish new content.


Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Linda says:

    Great news for the bears!
    Now for our beloved wolves!

  2. Alan Alejandro Maldonado Ortiz says:

    está con él la tiene que dejar de pasar no es posible que por diversión y trofeos siga matando animalitos son vidas

  3. Miriam schiro says:

    Yeeesaay! This gladens my heart but I’m confused because I believe they were protected before and hate the protections keep being lifted by unanimous votes of the conservative rights that are really wrong 😖 and scare they might still kill them on hunting season. But how can we still them from overturning a protection? How can we end hunting for good?

  4. Joan says:

    Yes!!!! I totally agree!! They need the protection of these laws and they need to be enforced. I believe the same protection should be available for all wildlife, including the beautiful, gorgeous tigers, lions and other wildlife!!!

  5. Melody Hagerty says:

    Now we just need to work on saving the other wild animals we have in our country from needless death ❤️❤️

  6. kimberly says:

    Great job thanks to everyone and humane society. Now time to protect all the foxes

  7. Sandra says:

    All Grizzlies should be !!!!LEFT ALONE!!! AND all wildlife should be protected from being used as sport hunting for SPORT!!

  8. Linda says:

    Our native animals are lucky to have the protection and ongoing oversight of the Humane Society and other groups .
    Thank you to this organization.
    Using firearms against animals proves that these trophies are not fairly earned.

  9. Sheri says:

    So glad this is finally happening!

  10. Patricia says:

    Good News! “Trophy” hunting with high powered rifles and scopes is not a sport by any means.

  11. Brenda Hixenbaugh says:

    Kudos for a job well done. Now if they would just step in and protect our wild mustangs and burros, please.


    The protection of these animals and all the others from the absurd hunt, should have been from the begining, just as laws protect our lives as human beings, they must protect animals as our equals. This must have been always!!!!! Why did it take so long to understand what life was about??? Why don´t we all work together to evolve???

  13. Laurie says:

    Wonderful news!

Share a Comment

The HSUS encourages open discussion, and we invite you to share your opinion on our issues. By participating on this page, you are agreeing to our commenting policy.
Please enter your name and email address below before commenting. Your email address will not be published.