The sad reality behind the ‘Best in Show’

By on June 30, 2022 with 8 Comments

Last week, a bloodhound named Trumpet won Best in Show at Westminster, after the usual spectacle: The presumably pampered pooches were paraded before a cheering crowd of dog enthusiasts. For some, such dog shows can feel like a celebration of the special relationship we share with our canine companions. However, there is a disconnect.

The attention given to pure-bred dogs can perpetuate misconceptions about breeding and dog health and welfare. For instance, due to selective breeding that reinforces particular genetic traits, ever-popular golden retrievers are at high risk of dying from cancer (roughly 50%) and approximately 73% suffer with hip dysplasia. Ninety percent of Cavalier King Charles spaniels, another prized dog breed, end up with serious heart disease by age 10. Doberman pinschers often end up with dilated cardiomyopathy (58.2%), a lethal form of heart disease that’s extremely common among these dogs.

And then there are bloodhounds like Trumpet. Bloodhounds are famous for being scent dogs, easily recognized by their size and skin hanging in deep folds on their face and neck. But these exaggerated deep skin folds come at a cost. Eyelids are meant to protect eyes, but if the lids are too loose, they actually catch bacteria and irritants. Some bloodhounds suffer from chronic eye irritation from the slackness of their eyelids. These exaggerated skin folds may also predispose these dogs to chronic skin and ear infections. And like most over-bred large dogs, bloodhounds are prone to hip and elbow dysplasia as well as cardiac disease. The chances of getting a healthy pet are even worse if the pet is purchased from a puppy mill; puppy mills do not screen breeding animals for genetic issues and are quick to cash in on trendy breeds that make the news.

The true costs of bred traits can be extensive, involving not just hefty vet bills, but the health, well-being and even the very lives of these dogs. If you have experienced any of these serious medical issues with your own beloved dogs, you know how heartbreaking it is. You know how much the dog can suffer and how expensive the veterinary bills can get as you struggle to treat these often painful and life-altering conditions. Much of this heartbreak is avoidable if dog owners, veterinary professionals and dog breeders collectively take a stand against breeding practices that have promoted extreme traits in dogs over their overall health and well-being.

A very short history of dog breeding

Dogs were selectively bred for thousands of years to fulfill functions such as herding, hunting, tracking, retrieving and guarding. Form and function were breeders’ top priority, with their focus on anatomical and physiological traits that promoted those functions.

As the years went by, more dogs were bred simply to be companions, and breeders started to selectively focus on looks desired by prospective dog owners as well as “standards” created by organizations such as the American Kennel Club and The Kennel Club in the UK.

The veterinary profession issued some cautionary warnings regarding this health-threatening trend. As early as 1967, the World Small Animal Veterinary Association committee appointed to consider breed standards in relation to the health and welfare of dogs stated: “‘Concern for the health and welfare of dogs demands that breed standards should not include requirements and recommendations that hinder physiological function of organs and parts of the body.” Unfortunately, these warnings were largely ignored.

Today, we see the explosion in popularity of breeds with extreme traits. That, combined with a lack of awareness among consumers and lack of genetic testing by large-scale, inhumane commercial breeders (puppy mills), as well as the internet sites and pet stores that sell these animals, has become a perfect storm that compromises dog welfare. As a poignant New York Times Magazine article put it years ago: “Inbreeding and other reckless breeding practices may not be as bloody as dogfighting or as painful to look at as puppy mills, but they may ultimately cause even more harm to the well-being of dogs.” That point was made over a decade ago, yet these practices continue. For instance, experts have been sounding the alarm about the health of English bulldogs for years; a new study released earlier this month cautions against buying English bulldogs because their bred traits pose dangers to their lives. And French bulldogs, a very popular breed also known as Frenchies, suffer from numerous health issues that are related to deliberate breeding of exaggerated characteristics, including a life-threatening condition that leaves the dogs struggling to breathe. The life expectancy of French bulldogs is now a startling 4.5 years, according to new research from the UK’s Royal Veterinary College.

What you can do

While so many people turned their attention to the Westminster dog show taking place just outside New York City, many shelters and rescues are meanwhile struggling with an overwhelming number of dogs needing homes. Many are at or above capacity, especially with larger dogs. The best thing you can do when seeking a pet is to consider adopting from your local animal shelter, where there are many puppies and dogs waiting to be adopted, including many mixed breed dogs who may have the hybrid vigor that translates into a healthier and longer life. Giving a homeless dog a new family is a far better option than purchasing from a pet store, whose dogs are almost always sourced from puppy mills.

If you’ve had experience with acquiring a breed with characteristics that caused health problems, you can help by sharing your story. Encourage your friends and family educate themselves before getting a new puppy or adult dog, including learning more about the health and behavioral history of any breed they may be considering. Be sure that any breeder has had pre-breeding screening tests done on their dogs to minimize the risk that health problems, heartbreak and high vet bills lie in their future.

Never buy a puppy or dog sight unseen. Reputable breeders do not sell or ship their puppies to pet stores or to strangers they meet online. Additionally, ask questions about the health history of the parents and the puppy. Ask for proof of health screenings and veterinary care. This resource can help distinguish reputable breeders from cruel puppy mills or other problematic sources.

If you bought a puppy that turned out to have health problems, you can speak out for dogs by reporting it to the breeder. If the breeder does not address the issue, you can report the problem to the local animal health authorities and to the Humane Society of the United States through our Puppy Buyer Complaint Form.

Follow Kitty Block on Twitter @HSUSKittyBlock.

Companion Animals

Subscribe to the Blog

Enter your email address below to receive updates each time we publish new content.


Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Alan Alejandro Maldonado Ortiz says:

    No es justo que estos animalitos sean forzados a esto, no es posible que mas animalitos sigan sufriendo y seguramente maltratados esto tiene que acabar ya

  2. Robin B. says:

    The breeders who show dogs at Westminister have spent 1000s of dollars doing health and genetic testing. They have contracts where only owners that follow everything to the letter are allowed to breed their dog. Please differentiate between back yard breeders and puppy mills and the professionals you see at Westminister

    • Amber says:

      That’s not what Humane Society was saying they were saying all the over breeding can cause problems I saw a trumpet in the first thing I thought oh my goodness look at his eyes they look red and a droopy anything that blows in the air iBacteria or anything will go into Heather’s eyes there are so many dogs at the different shelters and rescues that are beautiful and many people can find a dog like trumpet or Dobermans or anything but everyone doesn’t know that mixed breed dogs are much healthier

    • L Thomas Murphy says:

      A quick google search found several articles detailing cruelty at Westminster winning breeding operations. Sorry but when animals are exploited they always suffer.

  3. J Glaubitz says:

    Why are you PICKING ON big digs??
    The ancestor of dogs were wolves! Duh…they are bigger than most dog breeds today.
    ALL ‘purebred’ dogs have been selectively bred, especially the ‘little’ dogs, who also suffer disease and health problems just as serious. If Trumpet had been your precious little Pomeranian or your extra hairy Lhaso Apso…you wouldn’t even be addressing this issue.
    How about we just ban all breeds. 🙄

  4. Lori Cote says:

    That is wholly unfair, trash puppy mills, pet shops that sell puppies, backyard breeders…….but do not lump preservation breeders into that lot.
    Where would we be without well bred purebreds? You would never know what traits that cute mutt you bought will have as an adult.
    You will not know the character, temperament , size, exercise needs or coat requirements until they are fully grown. Then guess what, if it doesn’t fit your needs, it ends up at the pound.
    Very short sighted and ignorant

  5. Beri Bouwman Bek says:

    As a reputable Bloodhound rescuer for over 20 years, I see a problem with your argument against purebred dogs. For search and rescue, Bloodhounds are the Cadillac of the line for finding people. That’s what they’re bred to do. That one won Westminster is a miracle. They aren’t obedient or cuddly cute. As for puppy mill dogs, not a great choice. This is a giant breed. Most over are 100#. Although they’re are poor breeders out there, they don’t show up at Westminster.

    What worries me more are the “Designer Breeds”. Labradoodles/Goldendoodles. If you want a non-shedding dog, get a Standard Poodle. Labrador Retrievers and Golden Retrievers are great breeds, there is a reason why they are used for service dogs. With all the training that goes into service dogs, breeders are very careful to breed sound and healthy dogs that will live a long life.

    Your advice about puppy mills is good. I would add, be sure to be able to see where the puppy was born and at least the Mom dog. A reputable breeder is proud of their pups and cares where they go. They will stand behind their dogs for life. Don’t take the pup from it’s Mom and littermates until it’s at least 8 weeks old. Unfortunately Bloodhounds might be weaned young by Mom, but they need socialization. Things like housebreaking and biting aren’t a problem. This is true for all breeds. The AKC has a breeder list and also lists rescues for all dog breeds.

    Finally, Bloodhounds are a “lifestyle” dog. If you think they are lazy and sleep all day, they aren’t. They need a securely fenced yard. They shed and drool. They’re vocal. They think digging is fun and chewing is their job. They are lousy on a leash. There’s a reason tracking is called ‘dragging’. They are a giant breed. That’s why they end up in rescue. I suggest a shelter/rescue/humane society if you’re looking for a pet. Even purebreds are a choice:

  6. Becky says:

    Thanks for the informative post. This is really very sad. I agree with the opinion that it is better to adopt a dog from a local animal shelter than to buy from a pet store. I hope this and other similar posts will raise people’s awareness of dog welfare.
    At our company, we do everything to make your dogs as comfortable as possible. We have a team of caring and loving sitters who will treat your pets with kindness and tenderness.

Share a Comment

The HSUS encourages open discussion, and we invite you to share your opinion on our issues. By participating on this page, you are agreeing to our commenting policy.
Please enter your name and email address below before commenting. Your email address will not be published.